How to Make Stovetop Popcorn (Cheesy Vegan Popcorn)
Here’s How to Make Stovetop Popcorn (Cheesy Vegan Popcorn)! It’s incredibly easy to make and makes the best healthy comfort snack!
I’m not even sure when it happened, but at some point in the last two years I became the ultimate popcorn lover. I’m talking, popcorn became my go to snack, my go to comfort food, my go to “it’s late and I don’t want to eat too much so let’s make popcorn”. Sometimes I even have popcorn for dinner friends. So why, oh why, have I not shared how to make stovetop popcorn with you?
Somehow I categorised this under “oh well everyone probably makes stovetop popcorn at home“. No Jess. After expressing this you guys said you most definitely would like a quick and easy tutorial since stovetop popcorn can seem kind of overwhelming and complicated. I’m happy to say that it’s the opposite. I can practically do it in my sleep at this point in time.
How to Make Stovetop Popcorn
Let’s get right into it. Whether you’re someone who only eats popcorn at the movies or hasn’t found a popcorn you love, this recipe is for you. Why? Because it’s 100% customisable.
You start making stovetop popcorn by getting some fresh, high quality corn kernels. I love to get mine from a bulk bin or one of my favourite brands are Arrowhead Mills. I always get organic corn kernels. After that, I chose an oil.
Now, since I tried it once I always used Thrive Algae Oil for my popcorn. It’s smoke point is high and it never burns for me which I love. I have also use coconut oil and olive oil and I would definitely recommend coconut oil over olive oil since olive oil burns so easy with this. Just know that if you use unrefined coconut oil it does add a slight coconut flavour.
Now, we get to popping! Grab a large and high pot or a wide pot and put it on the stove. I’ll go through these details thoroughly below in the instructions but long story short, we pour our oil in and add three kernels and a lid. I can’t remember where I learned this three kernel rule (maybe even on the back of my popcorn bag) but this method means you get the oil nice and hot, until the first three kernels are fully cooked. This way, when you add the rest of your popcorn, the oil is hot, ready and everything will cook evenly.
When you hear those three glorious pops, open your lid and add in rest of your popcorn. Cover and lower the heat just a notch. I like to swirl to ensure all of the corn kernels are covered in the hot oil. Then I shake the pot for a good 30 second to minute straight. The kernels should begin popping and a lot all at once. I shake the pot about every 10 seconds until all of the kernels finish popping.
Now, I pour the butter over and I love that crackling sound (this helps the seasonings to stick), I toss it, then I add all the seasonings and toss again until fully combined! Then I serve and enjoy!
Now, the seasonings are what make this a cheesy popcorn. Nutritional yeast gives this popcorn the perfect cheesy taste. I use to make mine with only nutritional yeast (nooch) and salt but then I wanted more of a kick. I found that garlic, paprika and some heat REALLY took it over the top for me. This popcorn really nourishes my soul.
Benefits of popcorn
Before we get it twisted, popcorn itself it not unhealthy. A great whole grain, and is a great source of fibre. Of course movie theatre popcorn is usually slathered in all sorts of butter, coincidentally vegan or not. That’s not to say you can’t enjoy it when you go to the movies, but know that yes you can enjoy popcorn at home too! If you wanted to make this lower in calories, you could get a popcorn popper which would use air!
Stovetop popcorn vs homemade microwave popcorn
So I’ve tried both of these methods, and I prefer stovetop popcorn. It’s way easier to control, flavour and not burn!
How to keep stovetop popcorn fresh
How have I written over 700 words on popcorn? Anyway. Yes you can make a lot of this and store it in a reusable zipped bag to keep it fresh. I do it all the time. Except it usually doesn’t last cause I eat it, which is a difference issue, so you know.
I hope you enjoy this Cheesy Vegan Popcorn so much friends! Let me know how you love your popcorn!
How to Make Stovetop Popcorn (Cheesy Vegan Popcorn)
- 1/2 cup popcorn
- 3 tablespoons oil*
- ¼ cup nutritional yeast
- ¼ teaspoon sea salt*
- 2 teaspoons paprika
- 1 teaspoon garlic powder
- ⅛ to ¼ teaspoon cayenne or scotch bonnet powder
- 2 tablespoons vegan butter
- In a small bowl mix the nutritional yeast, paprika, garlic, sea salt and cayenne/scotch bonnet powder. Set aside. Melt the vegan butter in a separate bowl and set aside until you need it too.
- Heat the oil in a thick-bottomed pan over medium high heat. Make sure there's enough space for the popcorn since it will increase in size dramatically and very quickly.
- Add in three corn kernels, swirl to coat and cover the pot with a lid. This method means you get the oil nice and hot, until the first three kernels are fully cooked. This way, when you add the rest of your popcorn, the oil is hot, ready and everything will cook evenly.
- When the kernels pop, add the rest of the popcorn in an even layer on the bottom of the pan (see photo above). Remove the pan from heat and shimmy/shake the pot for 60 seconds off the heat. Add the pot back to the heat afterwards.
- Give it about a minute. The popcorn should begin popping a lot and all at once. Every 15 seconds or so I just shake the pot back and forth a bit. Slide the cover slightly ajar so release some of the steam on the inside (to ensure crispier and drier popcorn).
- Once the popping begins to slow down, remove from heat and remove the lid. Pour the butter over while it is still hot and toss or use a spatula to coat over the popcorn entirely. Pour the seasonings over and coat again until the seasonings completely coat the popcorn. Serve and enjoy!
Disclaimer: Although jessicainthekitchen.com attempts to provide accurate nutritional information, kindly note that these are only estimates. Nutritional information may be affected based on the product type, the brand that was purchased, and in other unforeseeable ways. Jessicainthekitchen.com will not be held liable for any loss or damage resulting for your reliance on nutritional information. If you need to follow a specific caloric regimen, please consult your doctor first.
ha! I love this. We eat alike a lot, I see. This is the only way I eat popcorn, practically. Never tried addition of paprika, but next time I will check out how it changes things. Thanks for the tip!
The addition of paprika is our worst kept secret we love the taste it gives when it hits the hot popcorn. We hope you enjoy Randy!
I also love popcorn, and sometimes have a huge bowl for supper after a long day at work. Will definitely try this cheesy version. Thank you xx
Popcorn after a long day is incredible! We hope you like it Sandi! Thank you for reading!
Hi Jessica. I just found your blog and love the recipes. So simple yet attractive. I’m actually looking to start a blog for people who want to eat healthier and I’m definitely going to link you.
Two questions: 1. where can we buy your food?
2. Where is vegan butter available in Kingston?
Hi Lorraine! Thank you so much for reading!
I’m so sorry but Jessica doesn’t cater.
Vegan Butter is available for purchase in Kingston at the following Locations:
1. Natural Health: Shop 18 Orchid Village Plaza, Kingston 6 (They are running low on stock right now so I would suggest calling before going)
2. Health and Nutrition Ltd: (Sovereign Center) Shop 7 106 Hope Rd, Kingston 6
Hope this helps! ~Courtney
Amazing!! So cheesy and delicious
We’re so happy that you enjoyed this recipe Caitlin! Thank you so much for reading and leaving such a nice comment!